The Very Group - Preloved - Model Update

All,

Please find our updated analysis on The Very Group here.

Note: You can also check The Very Group on the new Sarria portal here.

We had previously shelved our coverage of The Very Group following the April 2025 bond issue, which was allocated to one or two investors and left very limited liquidity in the market. However, circumstances have changed, with the potential for the bonds to be syndicated more widely than previously. The credit has significant sensitivity to consumer spending and bad debt performance, and we remain cautious due to the gap between Carlyle's reported valuation expectations and our own assessment, which remains substantial.

Investment Discussion

We previously held a position in the old bonds on the expectation that Carlyle would take control of the business and refinance the existing debt. This ultimately happened, but Carlyle refinanced through a private placement, expecting to sell the business in the short term. The sale did not materialise, and Carlyle subsequently equitised some of its subordinated debt to extend the private placement.

We did not re-establish a position following the April 2025 issue, as the new Senior Secured Bonds were never syndicated. However, the potential for an existing investor to exit its position has brought the bonds back into focus.

We would look to buy the bonds at around 90%, offering a c.13% yield. We do not see the business being valued much above £1.2bn and, with c.£700m of leverage, require a mid-teens return to compensate for the risks.

Downside would be driven by a further decline in retail sales. We forecast a 1% decline in FY27, an improvement on the previous year's decline of c.2%. However, a more significant deterioration in sales and/or higher bad debt impairments would put pressure on cash generation and could see the bonds trade below 80%.

Upside is potentially par, although this is dependent on the change of control provisions and whether a sale of the business would trigger repayment at par.

Key Conclusions

  • The Very Group is effectively creditor-controlled, with Carlyle owning the equity following enforcement of its holding-company security package. The concentrated ownership and bondholder base also create the potential for a change of control, although the timing and outcome remain uncertain.

  • Our valuation is highly sensitive to bad debt and impairment assumptions within the consumer finance business. Even relatively small changes in expected credit losses can have a material impact on profitability, cash generation and the overall valuation.

  • The Group has strong control over its operating cost base, but operates in a highly competitive and price-sensitive UK retail market, with limited pricing power. Its integrated retail and finance model remains its key competitive advantage, supporting customer loyalty, repeat purchasing and control over the economics of lending.

  • Active customers have declined to 4.1m, and order frequency has fallen to 4.2x. The completion of the Skyscape technology migration is an important milestone, but the key challenge is translating the investment into sustainable sales growth, improved margins and cash generation.

Ownership

  • Carlyle is now the sole equity owner, following enforcement of its holding-company security package.

  • The Senior Secured Bonds, issued in April 2025, were allocated to one or two funds and were never widely syndicated. There are now rumours that an investment bank is assisting an existing bondholder with the sale of its position. This could provide an opportunity to acquire the bonds at more attractive levels, although liquidity remains a key consideration.

  • Significant Gap in Valuation

  • Carlyle has attempted to sell the business over the last 12–18 months, with various reported valuations. Following the failure of the last sale process, reports suggested that Carlyle had a £2bn minimum valuation.

  • Clearly, this valuation was not achieved. Our own DCF values the business at c.£1.2bn, reflecting continued declines in retail sales in FY27 and higher bad-debt impairments. The significant valuation gap is a key consideration in our assessment of the debt stack and the return required to invest.

Happy to discuss.

Tomas

E: tmannion@sarria.co.uk
T: +44 20 3744 7009
www.sarria.co.uk

Tomás MannionVERY