Punch - For Different Reasons- Model Update - Positioning
All,
Please find our updated analysis of Punch here.
Too tight for our usual demand profile, Pubs are still better than cash and just as safe - these days anyway. So perhaps considering that we are already long Stonegate, it follows that we are also going long Punch, but we do so for a different reason. Stonegate is a momentum trade. The company still doesn't quite earn what it must, but positive momentum carries it. Punch does earn what it must and is taking advantage of its less liquid peers. This almost certainly means that Fortress will be looking to take bondholders for a ride again, but at this rate of investment in the estate and Punch's relative advantage in this business rates environment mean that we would sell this to our mothers.
Investment Considerations
We are buying 7% of NAV in Punch bonds at 103. The bonds are trading at over 7% YTW ('29 call at par), well too tight for what we are after, but better than cash and safe as pubs.
at just over 60% LTV and 3/4 wet led L&T exposure, Punch is in a uniquely strong position in this market and able to take advantage of forced sellers to add locations for an average of £700k.
The bonds are call constraint and will likely not appreciate much beyond their 2027 call price, and considering how close they already trade and the potential for a transaction involving parts of Stonegate's Platinum estate, there is even a potential for a refinancing at the closest call price.
Other than slight yield variations, we are not foreseeing much downside to these bonds in this environment, even as the British consumer is struggling overall.
Fortress’s strategy of converting L&T pubs into managed partnerships is delivering improved IRRs.
Long Term: Relative to Stonegate, Punch has less exposure to discretionary, late-night city-centre spending, which could ultimately limit upside when the consumer does eventually rebound. However, for now this scenario remains far off.
Q326
Standalone Q3 revenue of c.£90.6m landed squarely on our £92m forecast, so the top line is doing what we modelled: like-for-like price and the maturing Pub Partnerships transfers. Bolt-ons add estate, but the organic engine is steady. We expect this pace to hold into Q4.
However, looking back at our cost modelling, we were perhaps a bit overambitious. But even so, margins this quarter were lower than in the comparative Q325. Punch is converting pubs from L&T to Pub Partnerships at pace, and that conversion process is front-loaded on cost: fit-out capex, transfer costs, and a period where a pub being refurbished is either closed or earning below run-rate. The 60 transfers in 40 weeks is nearly three times the prior year rate. The short-term margin pressure is the price of running the programme at that speed. We are not expecting much improvement in Q4 on this metric either, because Punch will be front-loading its expansion relative to the life of its bonds to let it bloom in time for the next refinancing.
Working Capital was on target, but CapEx and M&A are dragging cash conversion down, so that despite the recent tap, quarter-end cash stood at a meagre £13m (with an undrawn revolver in hand). Still, at this pace, Punch will need to tap again or start drawing its RCF by Christmas.
New CFO Matt Ward (ex-Village Hotels, formerly Greene King and Hawthorn) joined in May, with Steve Dando moving to Chief Financial Strategist. A capital-markets-literate hire alongside an active tap and a stated appetite for further senior secured issuance is worth watching at a time when Stonegate is looking to sell large swathes of its L&T focused Platinum business.
Here to discuss this name with you,
Wolfgang
T: +44 203 744 7003
www.sarria.co.uk